{
  "scope": "Each independently checkable field claim is bound to dated source or new read-only table field; suggested workflow and limitations retain their declared evidence bounds",
  "claims": [
    {
      "id": "C001",
      "sentenceId": "S001",
      "text": "Audio-to-MIDI velocity gives you editable strength values for individual notes; inspect those values and the source-checked notes before changing track volume.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "primary-sources.json"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C002",
      "sentenceId": "S002",
      "text": "The comparisons below are a November 17 analysis of unchanged browser exports captured on November 16, 2026, with no new recording, conversion or model run.",
      "evidence": [
        "source-index.json",
        "/polyphonic-audio-to-midi/files/2026-11-16/browser-verification.json"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C003",
      "sentenceId": "S003",
      "text": "In MIDI 1.0, Note On carries a key number and a separate seven-bit velocity value, while channel volume uses a Control Change message.",
      "evidence": [
        "primary-sources.json",
        "https://midi.org/summary-of-midi-1-0-messages"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C004",
      "sentenceId": "S004",
      "text": "The inspected worker rounds model amplitude multiplied by 127 and limits its exported velocity to 1–127; that rule is not a decibel measurement.",
      "evidence": [
        "worker-velocity-rule.txt"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C005",
      "sentenceId": "S005",
      "text": "The saved guitar draft contains 55 notes with 34 distinct velocities from 28 to 109 and a median of 74.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "cases[0].n",
        "cases[0].distinct",
        "cases[0].min",
        "cases[0].max",
        "cases[0].median"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C006",
      "sentenceId": "S006",
      "text": "The piano draft also contains 55 notes, but has 40 distinct velocities from 29 to 107 and a median of 73.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "cases[1].n",
        "cases[1].distinct",
        "cases[1].min",
        "cases[1].max",
        "cases[1].median"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C007",
      "sentenceId": "S007",
      "text": "The direct mixture has 100 exported events and 51 distinct velocities, with its median down at 53.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "cases[2].n",
        "cases[2].distinct",
        "cases[2].median"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C008",
      "sentenceId": "S008",
      "text": "Moving the piano component later in the archived timing control gives a 101-event draft with 55 distinct velocities and a median of 59.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "source-index.json"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "cases[3].n",
        "cases[3].distinct",
        "cases[3].median"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C009",
      "sentenceId": "S009",
      "text": "These distributions include every stored event, including unmatched outputs, so variation alone does not establish faithful musical dynamics.",
      "evidence": [
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv",
        "velocity-analysis.json"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C010",
      "sentenceId": "S010",
      "text": "In the guitar ledger, matched outputs have median velocity 88.5 while unmatched outputs have median 65, with their ranges overlapping from 83 through 94.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "cases[0].matched",
        "cases[0].unmatched"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C011",
      "sentenceId": "S011",
      "text": "The piano split has medians of 82 for matched outputs and 59.5 for unmatched outputs, with the unmatched range extending up to 104.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "cases[1].matched",
        "cases[1].unmatched"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C012",
      "sentenceId": "S012",
      "text": "Among piano events with velocity at least 90, eight are matched and seven are unmatched in the existing reference ledger.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "cases[1].velocityAtLeast90"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C013",
      "sentenceId": "S013",
      "text": "That descriptive cutoff is not a deletion filter, and an unmatched event is not automatically an invented pitch because the crop and annotation have stated limits.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "/polyphonic-audio-to-midi/files/2026-11-16/protocol.json"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C014",
      "sentenceId": "S014",
      "text": "Matched labels are reused unchanged from the original exact-pitch, 50-millisecond-onset ledger, rather than reassigned using velocity.",
      "evidence": [
        "/polyphonic-audio-to-midi/files/2026-11-16/protocol.json",
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C015",
      "sentenceId": "S015",
      "text": "Sixteen guitar reference attacks already matched in both isolated and mixed drafts link to twelve lower, two equal and two higher stored velocities in the mixture.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "guitar-context-velocity.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "guitarContextPairs.sharedArchivedReferenceAttacks",
        "guitarContextPairs.lower",
        "guitarContextPairs.equal",
        "guitarContextPairs.higher"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C016",
      "sentenceId": "S016",
      "text": "Across those linked attacks, mixture-minus-isolated velocity ranges from −31 to +9, with a median difference of −4.5.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "guitar-context-velocity.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "guitarContextPairs.minDifference",
        "guitarContextPairs.maxDifference",
        "guitarContextPairs.medianDifference"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C017",
      "sentenceId": "S017",
      "text": "For example, the linked pitch-55 attack beginning near source time 10.054780045 seconds changes from velocity 95 to 89, while the next pitch-67 attack changes from 109 to 103.",
      "evidence": [
        "guitar-context-velocity.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C018",
      "sentenceId": "S018",
      "text": "Those links use known reference-source labels and original attack times; they do not mean that the model identified a guitar track or isolated the cause of a velocity change.",
      "evidence": [
        "guitar-context-velocity.csv",
        "/polyphonic-audio-to-midi/files/2026-11-16/ref-guitar.json",
        "/polyphonic-audio-to-midi/files/2026-11-16/ref-mix.json"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C019",
      "sentenceId": "S019",
      "text": "For the 21 archived piano matches, fifteen exported velocities are lower than the reference MIDI values, two are equal and four are higher.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "piano-reference-velocity.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "pianoReference.matchedRows",
        "pianoReference.rawDifferences.lower",
        "pianoReference.rawDifferences.equal",
        "pianoReference.rawDifferences.higher"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C020",
      "sentenceId": "S020",
      "text": "Export-minus-reference differences range from −42 to +19 raw velocity units, with a median absolute difference of 15.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "piano-reference-velocity.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "pianoReference.rawDifferences.min",
        "pianoReference.rawDifferences.max",
        "pianoReference.rawDifferences.medianAbsolute"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C021",
      "sentenceId": "S021",
      "text": "Among 204 pairs whose reference velocities differ, the exported order agrees for 118 pairs, reverses for 80 and becomes a tie for six.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "piano-pair-ordering.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "pianoReference.unequalReferencePairs",
        "pianoReference.orderingCounts"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C022",
      "sentenceId": "S022",
      "text": "Pairs tied in the reference are excluded from that ordering comparison, and these descriptive counts do not calibrate model amplitude to recorded key-strike velocity or acoustic loudness.",
      "evidence": [
        "piano-pair-ordering.csv",
        "/polyphonic-audio-to-midi/files/2026-11-16/piano-source-provenance.json",
        "worker-velocity-rule.txt"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C023",
      "sentenceId": "S023",
      "text": "A proposed flatten-to-64 edit would overwrite all 55 guitar values and 54 of the 55 piano values, based only on counting existing values unequal to 64.",
      "evidence": [
        "velocity-analysis.json",
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [
        "cases[0].valuesDifferentFrom64",
        "cases[1].valuesDifferentFrom64"
      ],
      "measurementDate": "2026-11-16 raw input /2026-11-17 descriptive table",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C024",
      "sentenceId": "S024",
      "text": "Keep the raw draft, correct source-checked pitch and timing problems first, then edit individual velocity values where the intended emphasis needs it.",
      "evidence": [
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv",
        "piano-reference-velocity.csv"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C025",
      "sentenceId": "S025",
      "text": "Channel volume and expression are separate controls, so inspect note velocities separately from those controller events and the receiving instrument’s response.",
      "evidence": [
        "primary-sources.json",
        "note-velocity-ledger.csv",
        "https://midi.org/midi-1-0-control-change-messages"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C026",
      "sentenceId": "S026",
      "text": "The older piano browser/offline comparison still differs at byte 122 in one velocity value, 56 versus 55, and neither file has been replaced or described as byte-identical.",
      "evidence": [
        "/polyphonic-audio-to-midi/files/2026-11-16/runtime-comparison.json"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C027",
      "sentenceId": "S027",
      "text": "The recordings, crop alignment, mixed-source construction and annotation uncertainties remain those of the original study, and no new listening, instrument response or general conversion-accuracy benchmark is claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "/polyphonic-audio-to-midi/files/2026-11-16/ATTRIBUTION.md",
        "/polyphonic-audio-to-midi/files/2026-11-16/protocol.json",
        "worker-velocity-rule.txt"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C028",
      "sentenceId": "S028",
      "text": "The included analysis script only reads the saved CSV, JSON and MIDI files to rebuild these tables, without decoding audio, running a model or requesting another browser conversion.",
      "evidence": [
        "analyze.py",
        "source-index.json"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C029",
      "sentenceId": "S029",
      "text": "The source comparison reuses a dated core-family review, not a current Google ranking for this phrase or a claim of exclusive functionality.",
      "evidence": [
        "research-review.json"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C030",
      "sentenceId": "S030",
      "text": "Use the converter when you need a new note draft, retain its raw MIDI, and use these archived examples to decide which note fields to inspect before editing.",
      "evidence": [
        "source-index.json"
      ],
      "fields": [],
      "measurementDate": "See source-index/primary-source dates",
      "newRecordingExperiment": false,
      "novelEditorialAnalysis": false
    }
  ]
}
